D-Link Forums

The Graveyard - Products No Longer Supported => Routers / COVR => DIR-655 => Topic started by: booglehead on April 15, 2009, 04:51:02 AM

Title: FIRMWARE 1.30NA and WIRELESS 802.11B
Post by: booglehead on April 15, 2009, 04:51:02 AM
ADD WIRELESS 802.11B BACK TO ROUTER

--OR

LET ME DOWNGRADE

Title: Re: FIRMWARE 1.30NA and WIRELESS 802.11B
Post by: EddieZ on April 15, 2009, 08:07:12 AM
tried downgrading?
Title: Re: FIRMWARE 1.30NA and WIRELESS 802.11B
Post by: lotacus on April 15, 2009, 08:12:49 AM
LOL I would like to see what happens if someone tries to downgrade teh 1.3 firmware.
Title: Re: FIRMWARE 1.30NA and WIRELESS 802.11B
Post by: EddieZ on April 15, 2009, 08:19:46 AM
Me too, before I upgrade  ;)
Title: Re: FIRMWARE 1.30NA and WIRELESS 802.11B
Post by: AWDL on April 15, 2009, 11:14:37 AM
The 1.30 Firmware has been taken down from the support site. It may do a little too much at once.
Removing 802.11b is not a bad thing for most people.
Conditions that make a firmware unable to be downgraded are not always avoidable.
Distributing a firmware that removed 802.11b and also will not allow the end-user to downgrade said firmware, could result in customer service or RMA issues neither the customer, seller, or manufacture desire.

Granted from what I have seen, people are reading the release notes and the warnings about the firmware, but I am looking to be on the safe side as the user base with access to the code made change (not read).

It may go back up because the benefits to the majority are to great, but for now we just need too take a closer look at the release.
Title: Re: FIRMWARE 1.30NA and WIRELESS 802.11B
Post by: EddieZ on April 15, 2009, 03:03:21 PM
The 1.30 Firmware has been taken down from the support site. It may do a little too much at once.
Removing 802.11b is not a bad thing for most people.
Conditions that make a firmware unable to be downgraded are not always avoidable.
Distributing a firmware that removed 802.11b and also will not allow the end-user to downgrade said firmware, could result in customer service or RMA issues neither the customer, seller, or manufacture desire.

Granted from what I have seen, people are reading the release notes and the warnings about the firmware, but I am looking to be on the safe side as the user base with access to the code made change (not read).

It may go back up because the benefits to the majority are to great, but for now we just need too take a closer look at the release.

Non-downgradeable firmware would suggest that the code base has radically changed. But still, regular firmware update routines clear out the whole memory space, so it is not impossible to create a downgrade path. Also because theoretically there is plenty of memory to address for such a feature. Will take some effort to add, but you will minimize the user discontent.

I agree with the b removal, but I can imagine the impact is great. And people should be aware of the releaslog, but we all know you only read them afterwards  :)

Title: Re: FIRMWARE 1.30NA and WIRELESS 802.11B
Post by: booglehead on April 15, 2009, 04:03:17 PM
yes, exactly what I did when my wife's laptop stopped working, checked the settings and read the release notes. I nice big FAT warning during the upgrade would of avoided this.

So how can I recover? I tried to downgrade but a message comes up like this:

(http://img4.imageshack.us/img4/2189/dlinkl.jpg)
Title: Re: FIRMWARE 1.30NA and WIRELESS 802.11B
Post by: EddieZ on April 15, 2009, 04:05:13 PM
There is no recovery possible...

I think it would be a wise thing Dlink came up with a statement of some sort...
Just applying the basic rules of customer satisfaction and damage control.
Title: Re: FIRMWARE 1.30NA and WIRELESS 802.11B
Post by: summerstormpictures on April 15, 2009, 04:30:33 PM
There is no recovery possible...

I think it would be a wise thing Dlink came up with a statement of some sort...
Just applying the basic rules of customer satisfaction and damage control.

Who at D-Link should make this statement? Curly, Larry or Moe?
Title: Re: FIRMWARE 1.30NA and WIRELESS 802.11B
Post by: EddieZ on April 16, 2009, 01:27:51 AM
Who at D-Link should make this statement? Curly, Larry or Moe?

That's probably one of the other issues, next to release management, test management and quality management  ;D