D-Link Forums

The Graveyard - Products No Longer Supported => D-Link Storage => DNS-321 => Topic started by: JoeSchmuck on October 19, 2009, 12:56:44 PM

Title: Does one drive have priority over the other drive in RAID 1?
Post by: JoeSchmuck on October 19, 2009, 12:56:44 PM

So, the question is...

  Does the left drive or right drive have priority over the other for reading or writing in a RAID 1 setup?

I ask because I have two different 1 TB drives in my NAS.  One is a green drive that runs at 5400 RPM (my new drive), the other is not so green and runs at 7200 RPM (my older drive of maybe 6 months).  If there is strategic placement of these drives, I'd like to set it up that way.

My file system is EXT3.

Thanks,
Joe

Title: Re: Does one drive have priority over the other drive in RAID 1?
Post by: Ryder on October 19, 2009, 07:32:18 PM

Quote from: JoeSchmuck on October 19, 2009, 12:56:44 PM

So, the question is...

  Does the left drive or right drive have priority over the other for reading or writing in a RAID 1 setup?

I ask because I have two different 1 TB drives in my NAS.  One is a green drive that runs at 5400 RPM (my new drive), the other is not so green and runs at 7200 RPM (my older drive of maybe 6 months).  If there is strategic placement of these drives, I'd like to set it up that way.

My file system is EXT3.

Thanks,
Joe

Good question Joe. My drives are twins right now, but if I ever have one die and can't replace it with the identical drive, this info would be handy to have!

Ryder

Title: Re: Does one drive have priority over the other drive in RAID 1?
Post by: gunrunnerjohn on October 20, 2009, 05:45:54 AM

I'd be somewhat surprised if it would make any difference, but it would be interesting to hear the "official" response. :)

Title: Re: Does one drive have priority over the other drive in RAID 1?
Post by: JoeSchmuck on October 20, 2009, 05:18:01 PM

It's possible it doesn't make a difference but sometimes the software may inadvertently favor one drive over the other

Title: Re: Does one drive have priority over the other drive in RAID 1?
Post by: jontomsu on October 20, 2009, 10:07:23 PM

Read over on the wiki that the right drive is the primary and the left is slave in RAID 1 config.  Nothing official from dlink though.

Title: Re: Does one drive have priority over the other drive in RAID 1?
Post by: Ryder on November 04, 2009, 10:50:38 AM

Just bumping this topic back up aways, would still like to know something official from one of the D-Link guys on this.  :)

Ryder

Title: Re: Does one drive have priority over the other drive in RAID 1?
Post by: JoeSchmuck on November 05, 2009, 02:15:01 PM

I know inside the box Drive 0 is the right drive and Drive 1 is the left.  I honestly don't see it favoring one but I'm sure it does in the code.  What's strange is if I pull the right drive and power on the unit it will report the left drive failed and the opposite if I pull the left drive.  Strange.  Yeap, running 1.03 firmware.  That problem my have already been listed somewhere in these forums and I'll have to look for it.  Can't imagine it's been covered.

-Joe