I'm not really sure how, but I seem to have resolved the issue. I did a factory reset on the router to try to fix a QoS issue and completely changed the network name/key. The only thing that was different was that the previous network name had a period on the end of the name. The new network name did not have any punctuation in it. I'm sure that has nothing to do with any issues I was having, but its the only difference in my setup. I would assume it was an issue with my laptop but my wife's setup was exactly the same.