@Hard Harry: As I've explained, the issue is not using my LAN IPs (192's). That works fine and all of my port forwarding works when I'm outside of my network connecting through my WAN IP (which is the IP address assigned by my ISP, given to the router since it's using a PPPoE connection to the modem). Theoretically, if I send a request to an IP outside of my LAN (ie. my WAN IP), it should go outside of my LAN to find it and even come back in if it's my WAN IP. That's how I see it anways and it has always worked on any router I've had in the past. I explained why I want to use my WAN IP/port forwarding rather than LAN IPs in my fourth post (above). Where did you see that "alot of people [...] got it to work"?
@davevt31, kthaddock: So is it an issue JUST for this router? It seems odd that they would take something like that out only for one model.