Up and running! I bought a little more expensive one and when I went to go to the wireless router page, it came up and said there was an IP or DNS conflict, and to click next to correct it. I clicked next, got to the admin page. Setup PPPoe, since before turning it on I changed my modem from PPPoe to Bridge Mode. Now I've got internet wirelessly throughout the house again!
I'm almost willing to bet now if I were to setup the old 835, that it would work now
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af375/af37530eb8a4d267fa3946a57cdbd261da5e4286" alt="Smiley :)"
So I'll keep it as a spare.
Thanks again so much for all your help! You've gone out of your way to help me!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d685d/d685d1bc5106a7c5c46f7e2597b97cfedef100ec" alt="Cool 8)"