D-Link Forums
The Graveyard - Products No Longer Supported => D-Link Storage => DNS-345 => Topic started by: Anvi on August 23, 2012, 11:18:48 AM
-
Transfer rates need to be fixed.. I'm getting 45MB/s peak transfer rate when moving files on local network to the DNS-345.
8GB file transfer:
LAN1 35MB/s peak write
LAN1+LAN2 45MB/s peak write
Sadly average rates are a little bit lower.. HDDs can't be the bottleneck here as each of them are able to read/write 100-130MB/s.
FW: 1.01
-
Well, for the first two or three days after upgrading to this v1.01b09 firmware, things were running at full speed and I was happy. Sadly, after that, it has gone back to being slow again. :(
I am experiencing much slower speeds than Anvi, above. I'm talking KB/s. Not MB/s.
-
The first two posts in this thread were originally located in the DNS-345 - Firmware Wishlist (http://forums.dlink.com/index.php?topic=47327.0) thread. These posts were moved here due to relevancy with the Firmware Wishlist thread.
-
WD Red NAS 2TB drives
RAID 5 configuration
Adaptive Load Balancing - 40MB/sec
Firmware: 1.01
-
Anvi, what type of hard drives do you have in your DNS? I notice my HDDs (Seagate 3TB disks) sounds like they're constantly powering-up and powering-down so I wonder if that is the cause of my speed issues...
Sadly, I don't have any hard drives to test with and am afraid that if I remove my current HDDs from the NAS, I'll lose all my files. I don't really understand how this works. Do HDDs automatically get reformatted when you insert them into the DNS-345?
-
HunterGeo, do yourself a favour and make a backup of your data. Any RAID setup is NOT a backup.
Hard disks don't normally get reformatted unless there is a problem with either the RAID setup or the disk is a new replacement but even then you have to confirm formatting.
If you do remove any of the disks in your unit mark them with the slot number so you can replace them in the clot you took them from.
-
Thanks, Ivan. I have a backup of the data held on the DNS on other hard drives.
Do you know what file system is used on the HDDs inside the DNS? I assume I would have to run a Linux boot DVD to be able to access the files on the drives inside the NAS if I take them out and put them into a USB enclosure...
Thanks for the advice. :)
-
If you used the default the drives should be formatted as Ext4 - at least ours are.
Because none of the available IFS available for windows read Ext4 then, yes, you will need to boot from a Linux live CD or DVD. In fact we have made our own live CD just for that purpose - as well as one for win XP to allow us to get at NTFS formatted drives.
I should have added earlier that you don't need another 3TB drive for testing, any SATA drive of any capacity will do - the main thing is that it is the same rating (SATA II or SATA III) as the one it is replacing.
-
Thanks for that, Ivan.
I have just noticed something very interesting.
Connecting to the DNS-345 via Finder is what has been taking forever to load things. However, if I use the Web Control Panel, and go to the file explorer and download files off the DNS using that, transfers are almost instanteous (for a 20MB file)...
I wonder if this issue occurs on Windows Explorer as well, or if it is just a Mac Finder issue?
-
Yup, just tried it in Windows XP (a virtual machine running on my Mac) and it transferred a 780MB file in 24 seconds.
So it must be Finder that is the cause of my issues.
I don't know if everyone else with speed issues is running a Mac or what, but this seems to be a connection to my issue...
-
It seems to be an issue with the SMB protocol in Mountain Lion. Will talk with Apple tech support and advise what happens.
-
Thanks for advancing our knowledge of possible solutions.
I wonder if the problem with SMB is also causing the frequent power-up of your disks because we don't see that here - the disks only power-up when the NAS is accessed.
-
I'm using WD Red 2T drives and getting roughly 30 MB/S transfer rates. Is that reasonable?
Update Sept 10, 2012: I'm using Ethernet Bonding configured with Adaptive Balancing and I get 80MB/S writes.
-
It seems to be an issue with the SMB protocol in Mountain Lion. Will talk with Apple tech support and advise what happens.
Why would you ever dream of running an open source windows network protocol from a Mac?
You can just enable afp on the dns and it should be fine.
You can read more what to expect at different raid levels here http://forums.dlink.com/index.php?topic=48231.0
-
@kave,
That might be fine if AFP works with windows in a VM - if it doesn't, then what?
-
Why would you ever dream of running an open source windows network protocol from a Mac?
I never knew there was an alternative.
Thanks for the tip, will give it a go.
-
Nope, still slow.
-
It seems to be an issue with the SMB protocol in Mountain Lion. Will talk with Apple tech support and advise what happens.
No problem with osx 10.8.1 and DNS-345. Transfer rate is about 45mb/s
-
Spoke with Apple. They reckon there are a few possible causes and the only way to fix it is for me to ring them when the issue occurs so they can troubleshoot it then (for some reason, in the morning it works fine and later in the day it doesn't). So I have to wait until it issue occurs during business hours and then call them...
-
Ok, so did some more playing around. Connected to the DNS-345 simultaneously in Finder via SMB and AFP.
SMB loaded nothing. AFP loads everything rapidly as one would expect.
This has remained like this for a good two hours now. Hopefully, that means my speed issue has been resolved by simply switching to AFP and ditching SMB.
Thanks, kave, for the tip!
-
Anvi, what type of hard drives do you have in your DNS? I notice my HDDs (Seagate 3TB disks) sounds like they're constantly powering-up and powering-down so I wonder if that is the cause of my speed issues...
Samsung Spinpoint F3s.
I'm using WD Red 2T drives and getting roughly 30 MB/S transfer rates. Is that reasonable?
Seems to be around the maximum that DNS-345 can transfer at the moment..
-
Seems to be around the maximum that DNS-345 can transfer at the moment..
Thanks Anvi for the confirmation....