So I FINALLY got it to work! YAY! I am now using my DIR-655 and love it! Since you all took the time to help me out, let me at least fill you in on what I did.
After trying everything I could think of, I finally broke down and called D-link. The service sucked, but there was one thing that the person told me to do that I hadn't thought of. Apparently my modem has a backup battery and everytime I would unplug it, it would just use the power off of the battery. The reason for the battery was to save the ISP settings in case of a power outage. So I unplugged the backup battery, waited half an hour (probably longer than I needed to), plugged it back in, and ran the quick internet connection setup on the 192.168.0.1 page. Once it finished, it recognized the modem, jumped on the internet, and too bad you guys can't see it but i have the biggest grin on right now! Finally after hours of figuring it out we all got it to work. So, if anybody else has a problem similar to this, check and see if your modem has a backup battery, because that might save you a headache, 4 liters of mountain dew, and a whole lot of time. Thanks everybody!